Lightroom “Edit In” Photoshop

If you use both Lightroom (LR) and Photoshop (PS) you have the option to open a LR file in PS (Photo | Edit In) for additional editing options, notably layers for more specific editing. Elements users have the same option. In LR preferences you can control how this image is recognized after editing. Just remember to “Save” and not to “Save As” in order to have LR retain image management.

In order to retain all of the advantages of both LR and PS my LR Preferences are to remain in 16 bit and ProPhoto and save the files as PSD files. If you prefer to export your images from LR you can modify the final output files in the LR export dialog. You can also “Save As” after having “Saved” the file for LR and put your file into another folder not managed by LR. I do this with files that are complete in order to fit them into my work flow coming out of PS. Doing both may be confusing if you are primarily a LR user.

If you “Edit In” PS when you open an original raw file you get no additional dialog box. LR adjustments to raw are just applied to the file as they would be from ACR. Saved files are new and the original raw remains. But, when you open a psd, tif or jpg file, including layered psd or tif files you have produced by previous editing, you get a selection box on how to handle the file. There are three choices:

Lightroom Edit In Dialog“Edit a Copy with LR Adjustments” – will retain any adjustments to the file made in LR, and previously edited PS files, but a layered file will be flattened so you will not have access to your PS layers anymore. A new file is created. This is the best choice for non-raw originals that have been processed in LR as the original file is retained. It is also what happens automatically with a processed raw file sent to PS.

“Edit a Copy” – LR adjustments will not be applied. Choose this to reopen a layered file previously processed, (initial LR modifications intact) but any modifications done in LR AFTER the original edit will not show up. Original tif or jpg files are simply opened as copies without LR adjustments. The result will be a new file.

“Edit Original” – (does not apply to raw files, remember) opens a file respecting its saved state, ignoring subsequent LR processing. Opening a psd or tif does not assume you want to return to the original raw file. A new file is not created, so using this option on an original tif or jpg file will be destructive.

Basically, there are choices to edit the original image or a copy, with or without LR adjustments. If you are working with jpg or tif original files the “Edit a Copy” options are the best.

If you are working with previously edited files saved as psd or tif files with layers, adding new LR adjustments will flatten your file. To work with these in their layered form you have the option to work directly on the file (original) or make a new copy, but with those options LR adjustments made after you saved the work from PS will be ignored.

3 thoughts on “Lightroom “Edit In” Photoshop

  1. I frequently use the “Edit Original” option when I need to do additional work on a psd (or tif) file that I have already edited in Photoshop and now need to return to Photoshop. After I finish editing in Photoshop and return to Lightroom (for the second time), the adjustments that I made earlier in Lightroom are still applied to the file. The other thought is that I do not want to create an additional copy of the file that takes up more space on my harddrive.

  2. Correct, Dennis, and you are opening your file for further editing in much the same way as you would using Bridge. The saved psd or flattened tif doesn’t rely on LR as the initial processing is “baked into” the file at that point. I do not concern myself too much with files adding to my drive space usage, but more with the multiple versions creating confusion in my brain.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s